Here’s what’s missing and how to elevate your audits beyond the basics:
1⃣Audit the Business Logic, Not Just the Code
A lending protocol might have mathematically correct code but flawed incentives (e.g., borrow rates that can be manipulated to drain reserves).
• Model token flows and game theory (e.g., "What if 80% of users exit simultaneously?").
• Use tools like @gauntlet_xyz to simulate stress scenarios.
2⃣ Upgradeable Contracts & Proxy Pitfalls
Storage collisions between implementation versions.
• Uninitialized proxies (e.g., Parity Wallet hack).
• Admin key centralization (e.g., Compound’s GovernorBravo delay exploit).
• Use Echidna to test upgrade paths.
• Verify initialize functions are protected and idempotent.
3⃣Cross-Chain & Layer 2 Blind Spots
What’s Missing: Contracts interacting with bridges or L2s (e.g., Arbitrum, Optimism) face unique risks.
• Message validation gaps (e.g., Wormhole’s $325M hack).
• Replay attacks across chains.
• Incorrect fee assumptions (e.g., L2 gas vs. L1 gas).
• Audit cross-chain call handlers (e.g., processMessageFromL1).
• Test with tools like @hyperlane or @LayerZero_Core for message integrity.
4⃣Formal Verification & Symbolic Execution
Tools to Add:
• @CertoraInc : Prove invariants (e.g., "No user can withdraw more than they deposited").
• Halmos: Symbolic execution for edge-case discovery.
Manticore: Explore all execution paths (e.g., for integer overflow).
Example: Use Certora to verify that a DEX’s swap function never lets reserves fall below a threshold.
5⃣ Historical Context & Attack Catalogs
Leveraging past exploits to guide audits.
• Study https://t.co/l3Q4YLLoZj and @immunefi reports for patterns (e.g., price oracle manipulation).
• Create a checklist of historical vulnerabilities (e.g., Nomad Bridge’s trusted initialization).
6⃣ Gas Optimization Risks
Optimizations can introduce vulnerabilities.
• Using delegatecall for gas savings might inadvertently expose storage (e.g., @SushiSwap's MasterContract exploit).
• Review low-level calls (call, delegatecall) for context assumptions.
• Test gas-heavy functions with EthGasStation to spot anomalies.
7⃣Governance & Multisig Threats
Governance mechanisms are prime targets.
• Proposal spam (e.g., @Uniswap's Governor Bravo delays).
• Multisig key leakage (e.g., @harmonyprotocol's Horizon Bridge hack).
• Audit timelocks, quorum thresholds, and veto mechanisms.
• Verify multisig signer rotation and cold storage practices.
8⃣ Third-Party Integration Risks
External dependencies (e.g., oracles, registries) are often trusted blindly.
• Audit @chainlink's latestAnswer staleness checks.
• Verify Uniswap V3 TWAPs are time-weighted correctly.
9⃣ Cognitive Bias Mitigation
Auditors are prone to biases like confirmation bias or anchoring.
• Use red-team/blue-team exercises: One auditor attacks, another defends.
• Rotate auditors mid-review to reset assumptions.
🔟 Compliance & Regulatory Traps
The code might comply with specs but violate regulations (e.g., OFAC sanctions).
• Check for view functions exposing user data (privacy risks).
• Verify blacklist/whitelist mechanics (e.g., @TornadoCash compliance fallout).